Is Traditional Publishing Right For You?
The biggest reason aspiring nonfiction authors fail is not their idea — it’s that their goals, audience, and publishing path are out of alignment.
In this episode, Meghan Stevenson makes a blunt but important point: if you want a traditional nonfiction book deal, you need more than a good idea. You need a real platform, a willingness to grow it, and a business model that can support the kind of sales traditional publishers expect.
What is the real reason most authors don’t get a deal?
According to Meghan, the issue usually isn’t potential. Most book ideas have it. The problem is platform and alignment.
Traditional publishers want expert and entrepreneur authors who can help sell about 20,000 or more copies in the first year. That usually means the author already has an audience, a business, or a clear path to promotion. If you are unwilling to build that reach, traditional publishing is probably not the right fit.
What does “alignment” mean in publishing?
Alignment means your goals, your business, and your willingness to grow match what traditional publishing requires.
Meghan gives one example of an entrepreneur with a coaching business who understood that she needed a much bigger audience to qualify for a Big 5 deal. She accepted that, grew her following to more than 600,000, completed a proposal, and moved into agent meetings.
She contrasts that with a respected executive coach who had strong credentials but did not want to be visible online or build a bigger audience. That person may be a great expert, but she was not aligned with traditional publishing expectations.
Why is platform such a big deal?
For prescriptive nonfiction, platform is often the deciding factor.
Meghan says the industry expects authors to promote, market, and help sell the book themselves. That is why a large, engaged audience matters so much. The book is not just about being brilliant; it is about reaching enough readers to make the publisher’s investment worthwhile.
If you do not want to invest the time, money, and effort to grow that platform, traditional publishing may not be the best path.
What separates the 2% who succeed?
Meghan says the people who do succeed are the ones who are willing.
They are willing to:
Build a bigger audience.
Put in the work to grow their business.
Hire help when needed.
Accept the industry’s requirements.
Treat the book as part of a larger business plan.
In other words, the successful authors are not just hoping for a book deal. They are building the conditions that make one possible.
What should you do if this feels like too much?
That does not mean you are failing.
Meghan is clear that traditional publishing is only one option. If you do not want to grow a large audience, there is nothing wrong with choosing another path. Self-publishing, courses, podcasts, or audience-building first can all be valid choices.
The key is honesty. If you want traditional publishing, you need to commit to the platform growth it requires. If you do not want that, choose a different route without shame.
Questions answered in this episode
Why do most aspiring authors fail to get a book deal?
What is the biggest dream killer for expert and entrepreneur authors?
What does platform have to do with traditional publishing?
How much do traditional publishers expect authors to sell?
What does alignment mean in the context of a book deal?
Why did one entrepreneur succeed in landing a deal?
Why did the executive coach not fit traditional publishing?
What mindset do successful authors have?
When is traditional publishing not the right path?
What should you do if you do not want to grow a large audience?
Get the Craptastic Mountain freebie here.
